Quick Summary
Anne P. Graham (plaintiff) supported Dennis J. Graham (defendant) through his pursuit of higher education during their marriage. Upon divorce, the dispute centered around whether Dennis’s M.B.A., funded by Anne’s income, should be treated as marital property.
The Supreme Court of Colorado concluded that an educational degree does not qualify as marital property for division purposes because it lacks inherent exchangeable value and cannot be transferred or inherited.
Facts of the Case
Anne P. Graham (plaintiff) and Dennis J. Graham (defendant) were married in 1968, with Anne working full time as an airline stewardess and Dennis pursuing his education. Throughout their six-year marriage, Anne was the primary financial provider, contributing to the household expenses and Dennis’s pursuit of a bachelor’s degree and an M.B.A. at the University of Colorado.
Despite Anne’s contributions, the couple did not accumulate any marital property. Upon Dennis’s graduation, he secured a job with a substantial starting salary. The marriage ended in divorce, prompting a legal dispute over whether Dennis’s educational achievements, supported by Anne’s financial contributions, should be considered marital property for equitable distribution.
The trial court originally ruled in Anne’s favor, assigning a monetary value to the M.B.A. and awarding her a portion of its estimated future earnings value. This decision was subsequently overturned by the Colorado Court of Appeals, leading to Anne’s appeal to the Supreme Court of Colorado.
Procedural History
- The trial court determined that education obtained during marriage is marital property and awarded Anne Graham compensation.
- Dennis Graham appealed to the Colorado Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court’s decision.
- Anne Graham then appealed to the Supreme Court of Colorado.
I.R.A.C. Format
Issue
Whether a spouse’s education, such as an M.B.A., acquired during marriage constitutes marital property subject to division upon dissolution of marriage.
Rule of Law
An educational degree does not have an exchange value or objective transferable value on an open market and is not considered ‘property’ within the meaning of marital property for division under the Uniform Dissolution of Marriage Act.
Reasoning and Analysis
Education, while a significant personal achievement that may lead to future property acquisition, does not fit within the traditional definition of ‘property.’ The Supreme Court of Colorado reasoned that an educational degree cannot be sold, transferred, or inherited and that it does not have a recognized exchange value.
Consequently, it cannot be treated as marital property subject to division in a divorce proceeding. The court also considered prior case law from other jurisdictions which supported their conclusion that enhanced earning capacity due to education is not divisible as property in a dissolution proceeding.
Instead, contributions made by one spouse toward another’s education can be acknowledged when determining maintenance or equitable division of actual marital property.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court of Colorado affirmed the judgment of the Colorado Court of Appeals, holding that an M.B.A. degree is not marital property divisible upon divorce.
Dissenting Opinions
Justice Carrigan, joined by Chief Justice Pringle and Justice Groves, dissented, arguing that the increase in earning capacity due to education should be recognized as a valuable asset resulting from the marital partnership and subject to equitable distribution.
Key Takeaways
- An educational degree is not considered ‘property’ for the purposes of marital property division in divorce proceedings.
- The court must consider contributions toward a spouse’s education when deciding on maintenance or equitable division of actual marital assets.
- Dissenting opinions highlighted that increased earning capacity due to education should be compensable in the context of marriage dissolution.
Relevant FAQs of this case
What qualifies an asset as 'marital property' for equitable distribution in a divorce?
‘Marital property’ is typically defined as assets acquired during the marriage that can be valued and divided equitably between the spouses upon divorce. Items included as marital property are those with tangible value, such as cars, houses, and mutual funds.
- For example: Two spouses may have bought a vacation home together after getting married. This property would likely be deemed marital property and subject to division in a divorce.
How is 'goodwill' treated in the division of assets during a divorce?
‘Goodwill’ in the context of a business or professional practice is often considered an intangible asset. Depending on jurisdiction, it may be divisible in a divorce if it was developed during the marriage through the efforts and reputation of one or both spouses.
- For example: A dental practice established and grown by one spouse during the marriage may have increased goodwill due to the dentist’s reputation, making it an asset subject to division.
Does contribution to a partner's education have value in divorce settlements outside of asset division?
Contribution to a partner’s education is valued differently across jurisdictions; however, it is frequently considered in spousal support or maintenance awards rather than as divisible property. The supporting spouse might be awarded more alimony recognizing their investment in the earning potential of the partner.
- For example: If one spouse worked full-time supporting the household while the other completed medical school, thereby enhancing future earning capacity, this contribution might merit higher spousal support after divorce.
References
Was this case brief helpful?